Solar PV DC Isolation Switches

Skyliner33

Skyliner33

Senior Member
VCDS User
VIP Member
T6 Legend
Just wondering how many people have a solar power isolation switch fitted to their system?
Something like this:

www.windandsun.co.uk

Kraus & Naimer DC Isolation Switches

Cost effective switches with a simple easy to install design.
www.windandsun.co.uk www.windandsun.co.uk

Also was your system self fit or not?

Trying to decide whether to fit on or not?
 
 
I will be fitting one when I do my panel. Just waiting for the weather to improve. I’ve gone for this (63A) from Amazon:

IMG_6844.png

Fitted into this from Screwfix:

IMG_6845.png
Whatever you go for needs to be double pole (2P) to isolate both pos and neg simultaneously.
 
Rioja John said:
Thanks @EAN Yes you are right I posted the above as I couldnt remember what I fitted, I will check it out this morning but I think I fitted a 40 amp isolator on my 200 watt solar system.

John.
Click to expand...
Remember to check the voltage rating as well as the current rating, to ensure both are compatible with your setup.
 
Skyliner33 said:
Just wondering how many people have a solar power isolation switch fitted to their system?
Something like this:

www.windandsun.co.uk

Kraus & Naimer DC Isolation Switches

Cost effective switches with a simple easy to install design.
www.windandsun.co.uk www.windandsun.co.uk

Also was your system self fit or not?

Trying to decide whether to fit on or not?
Click to expand...
I have that switch on the domestic PV system.

It's massive and not best suited to van stuff.

If you want a switch, get a smaller one, or a dedicated DC breaker.

As above make sure it's DC rated and have suitable voltage and current handling. Ie above 50v DC and 20A.
 
I don’t have an isolator on my panels, just a fuse. It’s adding complication & failure points imho. You have to find somewhere to mount it, it can be inadvertently turned on/off, it’s adding joints in the cable which will squander your precious solar yield. KISS.
Just my 2 penneth fwiw.
 
Salty Spuds said:
I don’t have an isolator on my panels, just a fuse. It’s adding complication & failure points imho. You have to find somewhere to mount it, it can be inadvertently turned on/off, it’s adding joints in the cable which will squander your precious solar yield. KISS.
Just my 2 penneth fwiw.
Click to expand...
agreed and very true.

( in fact a fuse insnt even necessary for small camper PV as they don't generate enough current to burn out a 4mm PV cable, or even blow a 1000v/30A PV fuse)
- https://amzn.to/4a3OWcV

as you say each connection reduces overall power to the mppt.


1711276328032.png


++++++++++++++++++

but there are two situations i can think of where a DC PV isolator may be required.

1- to disable PV in winter time when you have a lithium battery with no Low Temp protection.

2- to disable PV input to combi dc-dc+MPPT chargers ( like the renogy DCC50s ) to get full power from the engine bay and not split 50/50.



.....
 
Dellmassive said:
agreed and very true.

( in fact a fuse insnt even necessary for small camper PV as they don't generate enough current to burn out a 4mm PV cable, or even blow a 1000v/30A PV fuse)
- https://amzn.to/4a3OWcV

as you say each connection reduces overall power to the mppt.


View attachment 234237


++++++++++++++++++

but there are two situations i can think of where a DC PV isolator may be required.

1- to disable PV in winter time when you have a lithium battery with no Low Temp protection.

2- to disable PV input to combi dc-dc+MPPT chargers ( like the renogy DCC50s ) to get full power from the engine bay and not split 50/50.



.....
Click to expand...
Fair point, but in those 2 scenarios, you’re adding an isolator to overcome flaws further down the line. Scenario 1 could certainly be eliminated by speccing a decent battery. I’m not sure about scenario 2 as I’m not familiar with the kit, but it sounds like a fudge.
 
Yep, again agreed.

Some people cheap out, and get the basic options that miss out on features,

The PV isolator is a cheap way to get around these missing features.

I don't do this myself, I chose a lifepo4 with low temp protection, and run a separate MPPT alongside my dc-dc charger.
 
Dellmassive said:
Yep, again agreed.

Some people cheap out, and get the basic options that miss out on features,

The PV isolator is a cheap way to get around these missing features.

I don't do this myself, I chose a lifepo4 with low temp protection, and run a separate MPPT alongside my dc-dc charger.
Click to expand...
Yup, same here :thumbsup:
 
If you have a master battery isolator switch right next to the LB and fuse you'd want a PV isolator too, right? As there's big warnings about not connecting the panels to the MPPT controller without first connecting it to the battery. And if you use the main isolator switch, the PV would still be connected without its own switch.
 
My solar tails come through into the wardrobe where I've got a single pvc surface box with a domestic white moulded 30A double pole switch, think cooker switch here without a neon indicator and that's what I've got.
Turning off the solar means the Renogy DCC50S sends up to 50A to the leisure battery from the alternator via the starter battery and turning the solar back on calms things down by reducing the alternator input to 25A out of the DCC50S plus whatever the solar is actually producing as I drive around.
With two 175 watt Renogy flexy panels on the pop top the most output I normally see is sub 300 watt, maybe 260 odd watts and just sub 20A at 13.4V via the leisure battery shunt display.
 
Stay Frosty said:
My solar tails come through into the wardrobe where I've got a single pvc surface box with a domestic white moulded 30A double pole switch, think cooker switch here without a neon indicator and that's what I've got.
Turning off the solar means the Renogy DCC50S sends up to 50A to the leisure battery from the alternator via the starter battery and turning the solar back on calms things down by reducing the alternator input to 25A out of the DCC50S plus whatever the solar is actually producing as I drive around.
With two 175 watt Renogy flexy panels on the pop top the most output I normally see is sub 300 watt, maybe 260 odd watts and just sub 20A at 13.4V via the leisure battery shunt display.
Click to expand...
Bringing up this thread again as I am undecided about this. Do the regs for the UK not specify that a solar PV isolator switch should be fitted?

@Stay Frosty do you have a link for the switch you are using?
 
Skyliner33 said:
Bringing up this thread again as I am undecided about this. Do the regs for the UK not specify that a solar PV isolator switch should be fitted?

@Stay Frosty do you have a link for the switch you are using?
Click to expand...
I think you’re confusing large static PV installations with a low output mobile installation. Our 4kW domestic system gets up to 600V DC, so needs an isolator. I don’t think the regs extend to small mobile systems. As ever I’m happy to be corrected.
 
Salty Spuds said:
I think you’re confusing large static PV installations with a low output mobile installation. Our 4kW domestic system gets up to 600V DC, so needs an isolator. I don’t think the regs extend to small mobile systems. As ever I’m happy to be corrected.
Click to expand...
Its partly to do with regs, but the also for maintenance etc. Victron regs say the battery should be connected to the MPPT before the solar, and vice versa, solar disconnected from MPPT before battery. This is difficult without a switch.
 
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Blitz
Solar panel remote on off switch
Replies
3
Views
310
Blitz
Blitz
R
For Sale Brand new DC Rotary Isolator
Replies
2
Views
483
ReturnoftheMac
R
R
Campervan electrics proposal - looking for feedback
2
Replies
37
Views
2K
Atwcm
A
T
Victron 75/15 BT with Orion B2B
Replies
8
Views
480
ginkster
ginkster
D
Isolating Leisure Battery
2
Replies
21
Views
2K
roadtripper
roadtripper
Back
Top