Egr issues

Jp5037

Member
VIP Member
Hi just thought I’d share my experience with my 2017 CXGB 102 138k EGR issue and how I seem to have fixed it. I’ve had the van 2 months, warranty specifically states no egr repairs.
I did an apprenticeship in mechanics then worked at a used car dealers for a few years but left that trade almost 30 years ago, so I’m a bit rusty but somewhat handy.
I had a repeat insufficient flow fault for a few weeks which I reset with Carista almost daily, figured best change it. Bought a new EGR and cooler (aftermarket) from GSF and fitted it.
I would have done everything from the top without removing the tray had I not dropped a nut!
Like everyone says the bottom nut and t30 is the worst part but it’s not horrendous just use the right extension bars to sneak over the steel pipe which you can pull slightly out of the way once you take the T30 bolt out. I was surprised how easy the starter was to remove, (just bung up the hole with a bit of cloth). Refitted and bled the coolant manually with no issues. From start to finish took me about 5 hours but nextime easy in 3!
It ran much smoother at idle with no engine light on however Carista was showing codes P144000 egr open circuit
P0403 A control circuit
P0405 A circuit low
P140200 egr electrical problem
None of these faults would clear but I still had no engine light on.
I thought ok it must need adapting but coninuied driving with no issues whilst contemplating buying VCDS. I figured hopefully it’ll still do a regen so monitored DPF soot level. Luckily it was getting close to the 0.86oz that Carista shows it triggers on. Within a few miles hey presto it started to regen, once it finished I re scanned and to my delight all faults had cleared. It’s been fine for a good few journeys so far today. I’m pretty sure it went through a cycle and adapted itself. Maybe I got lucky? Thanks for all the info I’ve gathered on here regarding this issue
 
That's good to hear. I'm in the same boat and about to change the EGR valve and cooler. I have also seen the Hella one at GSF for circa £248 and wondered how you thought it compared to the standard one when side by side for build quality? Seems like a massive saving.
 
Hi the hella one from GSF is incorrectly listed for an T6 and is the older type, I know because I was about to start then double checked. Mine was £400 odd with a £100 odd surcharge so cost me roughly £300.
The quality of the correct one seemed identical to the original I took out. I really can’t remember what it was but Borg rings a bell. Good luck, it’s not too bad imo
 
Great write up.

I have a similar age van, same engine but below 50k miles and have thought about a pre-emptive change rather than it fail at in inconvenient moment. We all know they’re a weakness and will fail at some point - I’d rather be in control!
 
In my experience it should give some prior warning before causing bigger issues, I’d personally wait. As mentioned the insufficient flow was causing engine light almost daily for a good few weeks before I bit the bullet. Now my T5.1 had the same for over 3 years but would stay off for much longer periods hence why I left it. What you don’t want is the cooler leaking back to the engine that could cause huge problems.
 
…..I would say the one I took out was the original, can’t say if previous owners had issues but at 140k I did which was 3k after I’d bought it, so potentially you may have double the life left in it!
 
Thanks for the part number. I've just checked the gsf site and it says it doesn't fit my vehicle. Think mine is the older T5.1 engine in a T6 chassis. Oh the joys!
 
Just do a visual GSF said the hella was right going by my reg but it wasn’t. The type that looks like this pic was right for mine. Top of gear box 👍IMG_9087.webp
 
This is just what it looks like not the part no. Think this is a crafter although looks identical
 
Ahh yes that would’ve been like my 5.1 then. Put up with the code for years! Can’t comment on how difficult it would be. The wrong Hella one I had looked decent quality though 🤞
 
Back
Top