I think we'll agree to disagree. Over the years I've encountered evidence that an element of the premium is not based upon risk, but upon a customers financial profile and this their perceived willingness and ability to pay a higher sum.
There is some logic involved, particularly with brokers buying policies on the open market, but the logic extends beyond the obvious simple risk and commercial profiles into a financial profile for each individual customer they'd rather we didn't know about.
Yes - the ‘logic’ they use is let’s see how much we can screw this one over.
I’ve had vehicle insurance, sometimes four policies (for different vehicles per year), for decades.
Tried a lot of companies in all that time. Every year my car value goes down, I get another years no claims (they cap this so over 30 years of dodging accidents counts the same as 8, or 9, or 12… depending on the company). Most put the premium up every year now, in the last couple of years the trend seems to be to just arbitrarily double the previous premium cost - not much logic going on there.
I call and ask why? ‘Uhm, various factors.’
Can you tell me those factors? ‘No, there’s various factors.’ (Like explaining more than one thing is impossible).
Can you tell me one of those factors?
‘There are various factors. One might be insurance tax.’
I see, and I know it did go up by 2%. Can you explain the other 48% increase? ‘Well, there are various factors.’.
Sometime they’ll admit it’s just down to the algorithm.
Logic is built into these - but like anything computer based - if you put trash in you get trash out.
Basically they know we have no choice but to pay and they know the regulator is toothless these days and they want profit - like any business needs and wants.
But tell them you’re going to shop around… ‘Oh, well if anyone beats our quote (highly likely as this charade happens every year and we all know how it ends) then get back to us and we’ll try and match it’.
And all of a sudden their logic and algorithms go out the window - ‘Oh, well can match that, would you like to renew with us after we just told you various factors would double your cost and there was nothing we could do about it?’
Logic, my…